Geeks With Blogs


Geekus Con Livus Malcolm Anderson's home for Geeks With Lives
If you've never been a fan of TreeSurgeon ( then skip this post.

However, if have been there have been some interesting developments over the last couple of years.

The biggest one is T4

Recently Bill Simser wrote a detailed post about the potential future of tree surgeon,
called "Tree Surgeon - Alive and Kicking or Dead and Buried"

He raised the question:
Times have changed. Since that last release in 2008 so much has changed for .NET developers. The question is, today is the project still viable? Do we still need a tool to generate a project tree given that we have things like scaffolding systems, NuGet, and T4 templates. Or should we just give the project its rightful and respectful send off as its had a good life and has outlived its usefulness.
For myself, the answer is, keep it.

I've spent the last couple of years doing agile engineering coaching and architecture and from my experience, I can tell you, there are a lot of shops out there that would benefit from having Tree Surgeon as a viable product.  Many would benefit simply from having the software engineering information that is embedded in the tree surgeon site be floating around their conversation.

Little things like,
  • keep all of your software needed to run the build, with the build in the version control system.
  • Have your developers and the build system using the same build.
  • Have a one-touch build
  • Separate your code from your interface
  • Put unit tests in first, not last
I've seen companies with great developers suffer from the problems that naturally come from builds taking 3 and 4 hours to run.  It takes work to get that build down to 10 minutes, but the benefits are always worth it.  Tree Surgeon gives you a leg up, by starting you off with a project that you can drop into your Continuous Integration system, right out of the box.

Well, it used to be right out of the box.  Today, you have to play with the project to make it work for you, but even with the issues (it hasn't been updated since 2008) it still gives you a framework, with logical separations that you can build from.

If you have used Tree Surgeon in the past, take a few minutes and drop a comment about what difference it made in your development style, and what you are doing differently today because of it.
Posted on Sunday, July 8, 2012 8:20 PM Agile Development | Back to top

Comments on this post: Tree Surgeon 2.0 - The future on the T4 Express

# re: Tree Surgeon 2.0 - The future on the T4 Express
Requesting Gravatar...
I've always liked the concept of TreeSurgeon, so a revamp that takes advantage of things like T4 to allow selecting types of projects and allows replacing aspects such as unit test framework and libraries would be great.

I think some thought would have to be given to what part NuGet plays since it seems to have garnered quite a bit of mind share.
Left by Al Gonzalez on Jul 09, 2012 8:44 PM

# re: Tree Surgeon 2.0 - The future on the T4 Express
Requesting Gravatar...
This release adds the following features:

2005 and 2008 support in addition to the original 2003 support
Ability to choose the unit test framework generated (NUnit or MbUnit)
Updated tool resources to latest versions
NAnt build scripts will use the appropriate .NET versions (1.1, 2.0 and 3.5)
Minor bug fixes
Improved User Interface
Left by Boss on Dec 23, 2015 12:13 PM

# re: Tree Surgeon 2.0 - The future on the T4 Express
Requesting Gravatar...
I understand that one must provide a copy of the T4 forms and NOA that. it takes to process the application, they may request it in the future. Goatripsindia
Left by Rasika on May 14, 2016 4:24 AM

# re: Tree Surgeon 2.0 - The future on the T4 Express
Requesting Gravatar...
We have to dare to be ourselves, however frightening or strange that self may prove to be aamod resort shimla
Left by Rohan Singh on Oct 27, 2016 5:46 AM

# re: Tree Surgeon 2.0 - The future on the T4 Express
Requesting Gravatar...
Beauty is the purest feeling of the soul. Beauty arises when the soul is satisfied.
Left by nutnhuni24 on Dec 04, 2016 4:55 AM

Your comment:
 (will show your gravatar)

Copyright © Malcolm Anderson | Powered by: