Geeks With Blogs

Geekus Con Livus Malcolm Anderson's home for Geeks With Lives

So on a lark, I threw my hat into the ring for Portland Code Camp 2.0, I didn't expect to get accepted, there were already a few sessions on unit testing and nunit but I figured, what the heck, let's gear it for beginners, and do it in VB.Net.  Now I'm in the process of getting ready and I figured I should blog about things and or techniques as they came up.


For my first trick, testing a private method.

First rule of thumb: Don't do this.

No really, Don't.

You are locking the internals of your code down with your unit test, if you are having to test a private method, then chances are that method should be public on a different class.

However, if you are sitting in a situation where that kind of refactoring is just not going to be allowed and you still really-really-need-to-get-this-under-test, then this simple process can help.



Private Function Add2Integers(byval x as integer, byval y as integer) as integer

    return x + y

End Function


You want to get this under test, but you want this to be a refactor (which is NOT another word for maintenance, it's a word for code clean up, not feature changing) which means no changes as far as the users are concerned.


Try this, wrap the code in a compiler conditional, and then just call the function, and then pass the value back out.

Now your unit tests can access the private method.

#If DEBUG Then

Public Function public_Add2Integers(byval x as integer, byval y as integer) as integer

     return Add2Integers( x, y) as integer

End Function



One more time, really, don't do this, if you are not REALLY careful, this will come back and bite you hard.

Posted on Thursday, July 13, 2006 7:48 AM Agile Development , Stupid Code Tricks | Back to top

Comments on this post: Unit Testing a Private Method

# re: Unit Testing a Private Method
Requesting Gravatar...
very close minded article. something about old dog and new tricks coming to mind
Left by erebus on Jul 08, 2008 12:14 PM

# re: Unit Testing a Private Method
Requesting Gravatar...
Have you considered using Aspect Oriented Programming?
Left by Khaled Hussein on Sep 26, 2008 1:06 AM

# re: Unit Testing a Private Method
Requesting Gravatar...
I've used a private method to promote code re-use. Obviously this is preferable, as it reduces errors and code maintenance. This code isn't intended to be called directly (as it was part of a public method) so really this is definitely 100% the desired outcome.
Left by Terry Wilson on Apr 08, 2009 4:41 AM

# re: Unit Testing a Private Method
Requesting Gravatar...
I agree that unit testing private methods is a bad idea to do.

If you absolutely have to do this, try using reflection !

Cluttering the code with compiler conditionals just because of testing private methods seems a bit cumbersome to me.
Left by XiaoP on Aug 28, 2009 11:30 AM

Your comment:
 (will show your gravatar)

Copyright © Malcolm Anderson | Powered by: