Close this search box.

Make WPA Simple – Symbol Loading Is Not Slow

When you open an etl file you normally want to see which methods were executed most often. To decode the recorded stack pointers WPA needs your symbols. By default WPA adds the Microsoft symbol server to the list. If you click on Load Symbols

then you will experience some slowness which is very nicely explained by Sasha here: It is ok for the first time to get all relevant symbols from Microsoft but afterwards make sure you disable the Microsoft server from the symbol search list!

The symbol download folder is by default C:\Symbols. The directory after the srv* is the pdb download folder and after the second * the symbol server address is appended.

If you wonder why you need a SymCache folder:

The pdb format generated by the compilers is so arcane, bloated and parser unfriendly that the guys doing the pdb parsing within dbghelp.dll (part of Windbg) decided to convert the bloated pdb format into something much less bloated and much easier to parse. The SymCache folder contains therefore not the pdbs but the converted pdb files.

Here is the comparison:

And here the original pdb

Now you know why the SymCache folder is a good thing. You can safely delete it if it gets to big as long as you have the original pdbs still around nothing is lost. The vigilant reader has certainly noticed that I have added a path to C:\ProgramData\WindowsPerformanceRecorder\NGenPdbs_Cache. This is the path were WPR and xperf stores the generated managed pdbs while saving an ETL file to disk. By default WPR will create besides your xxx.etl file an extra folder named xxx.etl.NGENPDB which contains all managed pdbs from NGenned binaries. Since WPA of Windows 10 follows not its own convention to expand the symbol search path of the loaded etl file to its accompanying pdb directory I go directly to the source where WPR copies the generated pdbs from.

If you follow this advice and disable the MS symbol servers you will load the pdbs not within the next 20 minutes but in 3,6s for my sample ETL file. Kudos to the Symbol Cache and its inventors. While speaking of performance. PerfView has a much better (read faster) managed pdb generation strategy. WPA and xperf will call ngen.exe createpdb for each and every native image in the trace recording. This is not necessary since you can read the pdb age guid directly from the dll and check then in the pdb cache folder if the pdb already exists. No need to call ngen.exe all the time! Finally it is not necessary to copy the generated pdbs to the xxx.etl.NGENPDB directory. My own trace collection tool simply creates a directory link to the NGenPdbs folder and I have all pdbs I could need without any file copies.

If you find that the default paths of WPA, xperf, … on your crowded C drive leave no room for pdbs you can configure WPA to a different storage folder. Or you leave all as is and create with mklink /D directory links from your C drive to a drive which has enough space. I prefer the latter approach since in my experience tools tend to rely on the defaults and at some point they will come back to it (e.g. Windbg …).

posted on Monday, August 17, 2015 7:05 AM

This article is part of the GWB Archives. Original Author: Alois Kraus

Related Posts