Blog Stats
  • Posts - 27
  • Articles - 0
  • Comments - 70
  • Trackbacks - 124

 

ASP.NET Community/Portal Starter Kit vs. DotNetNuke

In my spare time (is there ever any?) of the past couple of days I have been manipulating both the ASP.NET Starter Kits and the source code from DotNetNuke . Both frameworks seem to have their advantages and disadvantages but I really like the DotNetNuke stuff a lot. You can take this source code, install it on a web server, add the SQL Server database (or Access if you really must), make a few minor “adjustments” and you have a pretty cool looking web app in production. As I am not that 'graphically inclined' (my wife thinks I see everything in shades of grey), the skinning architecture of DNN is superior to the Community Starter Kits and with very little tweaking, you can completely overhaul the visual identity of the site. Furthermore, there are numerous skins available for DNN where as the Starter Kits only have a select few (although these can be modified, you still need a graphical eye as to what looks good). I will continue to use both in tandem in my quest to conquer ASP.NET, but DNN is worth a hard look. 

Feedback

# re: ASP.NET Community/Portal Starter Kit vs. DotNetNuke

Gravatar I'm actually playing with the community starter kit now...I have to admit it's really easy to get up and running out of the box.

Going to go have a look at DNN now though, just to compare. Thanks. 6/16/2004 12:54 PM | Scott C Reynolds

# re: ASP.NET Community/Portal Starter Kit vs. DotNetNuke

Gravatar I think you'll fine DNN is pretty easy to get going as well. I'm running WWWCoder.com on it, and it handles the load easily and I can write modules for it and extend it pretty easy. I noticed today that IISFaq.com moved to DNN, and PDABuzz.com also runs it. I think you're going to see more sites moving over to it as time goes by. 6/18/2004 2:13 PM | Patrick Santry

# re: ASP.NET Community/Portal Starter Kit vs. DotNetNuke

Gravatar I just starting into asp.net and was wondering, is it easy to create my own web application (a case management system where user creates, deletes and edit information called from sql server using stored procedure) and then use it through DNN? Are there any examples out on web where my web app can be integrated into DNN and the use DNN security to handle what contols a user has access to.

thanks
Nick 10/23/2004 5:49 PM | Nick

# re: ASP.NET Community/Portal Starter Kit vs. DotNetNuke

Gravatar None of the sites running DNN work 12/16/2004 2:30 PM | Joe

# re: ASP.NET Community/Portal Starter Kit vs. DotNetNuke

Gravatar I am working with the newest version and DNN 3.0.7 and it works great on my local system but all I get are errors and errors when I load it on the server. very frustrating. 12/23/2004 2:35 PM | Trevor

# re: ASP.NET Community/Portal Starter Kit vs. DotNetNuke

Gravatar I'm a newbie to both - but for me, CSK is easier than DNN. One feature I miss on CSK that DNN has built in - the ability to approve registrations before a visitor gets access to the site. You can build a custom module to handle that in CSK - but I'm not quite ready to tackle that. I've also found better support pages / resources - including a book, dedicated to the starter kits. 1/13/2005 12:40 AM | Sue

Post a comment





 

Please add 1 and 4 and type the answer here:

 

 

Copyright © Kyle Hebb - Off the Beaten Path