Color Me...

Yes, color...

I took a quick look through Google to get an idea of colors vs moods, and just grabbed the first site that popped up. The site isn't important, but I wanted to give credit. I was more interested in the correlation such as:

  • Blue:     Calm, harmony
  • Black:   Formality, elegance
  • Green: Nature, Jealousy
  • Purple: Royalty
  • Red:     Love, danger (whoa... interesting juxtaposition)
  • White:  Reverence, Innocence
  • Yellow: Joy, Optimism

And why did I go on this search? ... I was looking to see if I could find a color for my mood after hearing from Page Brooks about the results of our Silverlight Control Builder Contest.

I thought the contest was a great way to get the community of developers fired up to build some very cool controls. I had an MSDN subscription to give away that I thought would make a great prize. That subscription limited us to US entrants only, unfortunately.

In 45 days, Page had 2300 unique visitors, and 9500 page views on the site. I hesitate to guess how many US Silverlight developers there are, but I'm going to guess there's more than a few. I had enlisted some Silverlight Superstars to help judge, and had a group of names on the tip of my tongue if we needed more. I'm pretty sure I was thinking in terms of 25 entries. We didn't get that many.

That list of prizes for the winner totalled out about $17,000 ... seriously... and made me worried we'd have a lot more than 10 or 15 entries. We didn't get that many.

Maybe it's just me, but I looked at that list of prizes from: Telerik, Xceed, Devexpress, Infragistics, and O'Reilly, and I thought "man ... the winner (or winners) of this thing are going to be contacted about jobs, or writing a book... how cool is that?" But then that worried me that we'd have a lot more than 5 or 10 entries. We didn't get that many.

We very obviously had been in contact with some Silverlight Team Project Managers at Microsoft, and global visibility of any of the entries would boost a developer's street cred' instantaneously... and I worried we'd have more than 3 to 5 entries. We didn't get that many. 

Page has said the contest failed, but I don't think it did... I think the developers failed. The site was great, we all blogged about it, just on the basis of how cool an idea it was, we got all sorts of very nice prizes offered to us to give away, and I'd like to personally thank all the contributors for that! I don't think there's any more that could have been done other than drop the MSDN subscription and make it world-wide, because obviously there was only 1 Silverlight Developer in the entire United States that wanted to enter.

Congratulations to our winner (I'll not name the winner here, I'll let Page do that on his site), not only did you submit, but you submitted a very cool control that I find addictive :)

And for your efforts, you take everything off the top shelf of prizes... how cool is that?

As for everyone else, I looked through that color vs mood list, and I couldn't find a suitable color, so just

Color me ... Disappointed.

Stay in the 'Light!

-Dave

 

posted @ Tuesday, August 12, 2008 9:47 PM

Print

Comments on this entry:

# re: Color Me...

Left by Ian at 8/12/2008 10:36 PM
Gravatar
I think the decision to limit the contest to US residents put a severe dent in it's credibility. Most people from non-US countries would have been happy to enter without the lure of the MSDN subscription (a lot of us already have one).

# re: Color Me...

Left by Anna at 8/13/2008 12:42 AM
Gravatar
What he said... I live in Poland, speak English, have a PayPal account, can receive e-mail and paper mail,... and still I'm banned from many sites (*coughitunescough*) and contests (*coughthinkgeektshirtscough*)... :(

I know some prizes are sometimes irrelevant or more expensive to ship than they are worth in the cases of some foreign countries. But how about I decide sometimes if I wanna take part in a contest, even if that means giving up on the material prizes?

And what about all the "it's not about the prize" talks we all heard as kids? For those of us who can't receive the prizes, contests are strictly about the fun and the satisfaction - so why does this disqualify us?

# re: Color Me...

Left by Nick at 8/13/2008 1:40 AM
Gravatar
Can I add that NBC/Silverlight buzz is all invisible to the majority of the Silverlight developers?
Devs in other countries have more interest in this type of contests than US devs.
At the end of the day, there was no contest. One submission/one winner cannot be called contest.
I live in Ireland. :(

# re: Color Me...

Left by Anna at 8/13/2008 2:33 AM
Gravatar
Yeah, I think the promotion was good. I knew about the contest a month ago (and I started doing SL a month ago) but my reaction was "pfff, U.S. onyl again..."

Interesting how the map next to my previous comment illustrates our point.

# re: Color Me...

Left by JasonBSteele at 8/13/2008 3:42 AM
Gravatar
I had a good idea for a Control that I wanted to submit... but then found it was for U.S. only. I believe I posted my dissapointment at the time.

-Jason, UK

# re: Color Me...

Left by Jim at 8/13/2008 5:17 AM
Gravatar
As a US developer, I did not enter because the most visually compelling and interesting controls that I'm developing are going into a product that I want to generate some income with. Perhaps that is something the sponsors of the contest could take away. This tool is the sleeper product of the year in my opinion. I have done in 10 weeks what I could not finish in 3 years of spare time before this tool. It has the capability of giving developers an incredible edge in designing portable applications that are rich and deep. J

# re: Color Me...

Left by Rob Burke at 8/13/2008 5:45 AM
Gravatar
Ian beat me to it - I'm in Canada and am getting tired of being excluded from the shindigs. Heck, we get HD NBC coverage on TV here and I'd been beating the drum about Silverlight Olympics for months but can't re-watch the Opening Ceremonies at NBC's site. What a farce. It's becoming a pattern.

Also, remember that Silverlight 2 is a beta technology. Those of us on the frontier are not just building controls, we're also devoting our time to exploring what we can do creatively with the technology (even silly contributions like the POC FractLOL on my blog).

Apologies for a frustrated response, but I feel as though, after all your thoughtful work on this blog, you are taking an inappropriate swipe at the quality and initiative of the Silverlight developer community. You also detract from the accomplishment of your winners with these sentiments. I appreciate your disappointment but please do know that there's an enthusiastic community out here spending spare time building things with the Silverlight beta, even if we don't stand to receive prizes for our efforts.

# re: Color Me...

Left by Michael at 8/13/2008 5:48 AM
Gravatar
If I could only... I am still learning Silverlight. There is no way this boy from Kansas could submit any control yet.

# re: Color Me...

Left by John Rennemeyer at 8/13/2008 6:40 AM
Gravatar
I agree with most of the comments. Since Silverlight 2 is still beta technology, I've been focusing on developing a WPF application in hopes that I can take my WPF knowledge and apply it over to Silverlight 2 when it is released. I think taking the prizes leftover and possibly holding onto them until after Silverlight 2 RTM would be a good idea. Remember, WPF and Silverlight have a steep learning curve.

Also, I remember seeing the 20 day remaining post (the first post I saw about he contest), http://geekswithblogs.net/WynApseTechnicalMusings/archive/2008/07/22/123956.aspx, and read the part about the list of prizes (and this may seem silly on my part), but I didn't see a direct link to the list of prizes. In my mind, this read as, "I have a list of prizes that is unbelievable, but I'm not gonna show you what they are.". I didn't realize that the main contest page actually had the prizes listed, so at the time, this sounded like a bunch of hoopla in hopes to entice people to enter. I think I read the post early the next morning so my "thinking cap" was still in bed (I wish I had been). If you had more directly given a snippet of the prizes in your blog post, I think that would've been helpful in getting more people interested.

I'm a US citizen so I can't complain in that regard other than I agree with having the contest open to all with a caveat that if you are outside of the US some of the prizes could not be awarded to them and if the winner had a friend in the US, they transfer the prize to them.

# re: Color Me...

Left by John Stockton at 8/13/2008 8:47 AM
Gravatar
I am as disappointed as you on the lack of entries. I agree that teh US only requirement certinly cut down on the number of possible entries but still, only one?

I had started creating a control to submit but then got in way too deep on overcommiting myself to other things, like moving, findina new job, selling my house, finishing a chapter, writing a new presentation. You know, little things like that :).

Please don't take the lack of participation this time as an indication of the contest as a whole, for me or others. I truly appreciate what you two put together and hope I see more things like this in the future.

# re: Color Me...

Left by futureturnip at 8/13/2008 12:30 PM
Gravatar
I'd agree, US based restrictions stink. I couldn't believe that the nbcolympics are US only. What's the web coming to? The world is a small place, and getting smaller everyday after all.

As far as the contest goes, I believe the timing and the contest duration might have been contributing factors; timing; lots of people still trying to climb the learning curve prior to RTM with competition for brain space from everything from WPF to MVC, and duration; because we just didn't have enough time to get our heads around making a control.

If something like this happens again, and you don't have some min. # of entrants; could I suggest you extend the deadline (with sufficient yelling and flogging)?

# re: Color Me...

Left by Rui at 8/14/2008 8:50 AM
Gravatar
Hope that contest to non-us developers and u should have a suprise :)

Rui

Portugal

# re: Color Me...

Left by Chris Cavanagh at 8/14/2008 10:20 AM
Gravatar
Dang, I had some cool stuff I was going to submit to this, but stupidly forgot :( Still, I'm surprised there wasn't a decent turnout. Maybe everyone's moving to Flash 10? ;)

# re: Color Me...

Left by Sean Blakemore at 8/15/2008 12:23 AM
Gravatar
I'm sorry to hear it didn't take of the way you'd hoped, it can't be a nice feeling that you went to all that effort and had no response.

I do just want to add my +1 to the US restriction being what stopped me. I remember reading about the contest and getting excited, I already have a control I was going to give a little polish and enter, and then getting to the US restriction part and being 'coloured disappointed' myself. (Note the 'u' in colour!)

# re: Color Me...

Left by Parag Mehta at 8/19/2008 4:01 AM
Gravatar
Well I don't think people will post their hard-earned controls for free specially when it's new technology. Everyone is planning on getting rich rather then gaining community recognition at this time. The prizes are good but not all worthy. Look for eg a Upload control that you count as $400 can be built by any silverlight developer in couple of hours! MSDN was a biggie there but then again I would think those doing Silverlight might already have MSDN since they are using VS 2008.

Your comment:



 (will not be displayed)


 
 
 
 

Live Comment Preview:

 
«July»
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
2829301234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
2627282930311
2345678